Guidelines for Reviewers

All full paper submissions are put through a double-blind review process. This means that you as a reviewer need to give comments without giving away your identity. All comments you make will be made available for the authors. Please, treat all manuscripts as confidential documents.

You are strongly encouraged to provide constructive feedback to authors about necessary changes and recommended changes for accepting the manuscript. Your final recommendation is in the forms of:

  • Accept (as is or with minor revisions)
  • Minor revision (as conditional acceptance if authors appropriately address significant but fairly straightforward revisions)
  • Major revision (consider accepting if authors make significant revisions, such as to address important conceptual issues or additional analyses)
  • Reject (resubmitting as work-in-progress)

 Review form is available in a Word document format.

We would like to thank all reviewers! – for the effort and expertise that you contribute to reviewing, without which it would be impossible to maintain the high standards of NOFOMA Conferences.